Evidence supporting the use of: Comfrey
For the body system: Skeletal System (Bones)
Synopsis
Source of validity: Traditional
Rating (out of 5): 3
Comfrey (Symphytum officinale) has been traditionally used for centuries to support bone healing and musculoskeletal health. The plant was commonly referred to as "knitbone" in folk medicine, reflecting its historical use in treating fractures, sprains, and bruises. Comfrey roots and leaves contain allantoin, a compound believed to promote cell proliferation and tissue repair, as well as rosmarinic acid and other phytochemicals with anti-inflammatory effects. Historical records from Europe and Asia detail applications of comfrey poultices or compresses directly to the skin over fractures or injuries, and its use persists in some herbal traditions today.
However, modern clinical evidence for comfrey's effectiveness in supporting the skeletal system is limited and largely restricted to topical applications. Some small studies and case reports suggest that comfrey ointments may help reduce pain and inflammation in minor injuries, but robust clinical trials specifically investigating bone healing are lacking. Importantly, comfrey contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids, compounds known to be hepatotoxic and potentially carcinogenic if ingested or used chronically. Because of these safety concerns, internal use of comfrey is discouraged in most countries.
In summary, comfrey's use for bone support is primarily based on traditional knowledge and historical practices, with limited scientific validation and significant safety concerns regarding internal use.
Other ingredients that support Skeletal System (Bones)
AchyranthesAlfalfa
Algae
Algas calcareas
alpha-ketoglutarate (AKG)
amino acids
animal protein
antler
arugula
baicalein
beef
bone marrow
bone protein
boneset
boron
Boswellia
Boswellic Acid
bovine
bovine cartilage / glycosaminoglycan
bovine protein
broccoli
Buckwheat
calcium
cartilage
Chinese mountain ant
Chinese pond turtle
Chinese salvia root
Chinese silkvine
chondroitin
chuchuhuasi
Cissus quadrangularis
citrate malate
cod liver oil
collagen
collard
comfrey
Corallina officinalis
cruciferous
daidzein
deer velvet
devil's claw
Dipsacus
dolomite
Drynaria
egg
elk antler
estrogen
eucommia
Eucommia ulmoides
fibroblast growth factor
fish
fish protein
Foxtail millet
fructoborate
genistein
genistin
Glycosaminoglycans
green-lipped mussel
herbal blend (proprietary)
HMB hydroxymethylbutyrate
horse gram
horsetail
hydroxyproline
icariin
Indian frankincense
ipriflavone
isoflavones
Kaempferol
Ledebouriella
Legume protein
Lithothamnion
magnesium
manganese
Microcrystalline hydroxyapatite concentrate (MCHC)
Milk
Milk Protein
Mineral blend
Molasses
Osthole
Peptides
phosphorus
Phytoestrogens
Polygonatum
protein
proteoglycans
prune
Rehmannia
rehmannia glutinosa
seaweed
sesame
Shilajit
silicon
Sinomenium acutum
solomon's seal
Soy
soy isoflavones
Soy Protein
Spatholobus
spinach
strontium
Taxillus chinensis
Taxillus sutchuenensis
trace minerals
vitamin C
vitamin D
vitamin D3
vitamin K
